comments on NMC.

by Siena Anstis on January 23, 2026 · 6 comments

in NMC

I am now back in Nairobi with a bit of time to reflect on the 1st NMC World Youth Meeting for Sustainable Development. Generally, I would not be one to write a critique of a conference (usually I just enjoy them and move on), but considering that at least $2,500,000 was poured into this event, I hope the NMC committee will actually consider the following thoughts as they continue their work.

First of all, a conference like this is an excellent time to network. Those who know me understand how much I dislike that word. However, for once, this conference made networking a fun activity where interesting people were given a chance to meet on an equal level. While little time was spent speaking about sustainable development or suggested policy changes, we did have a great time in the evenings simply getting to know each other. This type of networking I always value.

However, aside from the networking component, the NMC meeting offered considerably less than I expected. Major concerns that emerged (echoed by several fellow delegates) dealt with the following. If you are organizing a youth conference where you want youth to influence policy and develop and engage a large network to debate within, bear these points in mind:

1. Repetitive: Of course, it’s great to be invited to Bari for free and spend a few days in Southern Italy. It was also fantastic to meet more and more people. However, several of these conferences already exist on an international scale. I am not sure we need new ones. World Youth Congress, UNESCO’s World Youth Forum, Asian Youth Forum and so on offer the same valuable opportunity to network.

2. NMC’s Objective: During a meeting with the members who started the NMC concept, it soon became clear that their vision was still blurry. By hosting a conference while still not sure of their own mandate, they are wasting the valuable energy and time of youth participants. As a colleague said, when we have no goal to work towards - i.e. NMC’s blurry objective of engaging youth in policy-decision making (how?) - the desired motivation after is limited.

3. Format: Basically, the three days split up into several components. We had on and off plenaries with one or two interesting speakers. The others seemed to be offering a resume of their own work or their organization’s mandates. We then had capacity-building workshops. Not all were well attended and the facilitators seemed disappointed. These workshops covered a variety of things from entrepreneurship to combating organized youth crime. A third component was the “Bar Camp.” I did not attend any events here, but I also heard that some delegate presenters did not show up and attendance was low. Lastly, we had about 8-hours of workshops. In theory, we were allowed to move between different workshops and get a sampling of all things happening at the conference. However, within the workshops we were supposed to put together “action plans” (basically, policy papers with concrete solutions). In eight hours, putting together quality material that would have a real impact on international policy-making was impossible. Instead, I would say that most of what we all produced was a joke, populated by the very vacant words that we constantly complain about. The difficulty of this situation was compounded by irregular attendance on the behalf of delegates.

4. Dissemination of Action Plans: I was told just after the presentation of the action plan that the press attended this part of the event. What the groups produced was seriously flawed and unprofessional (not by our own fault but through a lack of guidance, concrete objectives, inspiration and time). I can only hope that the press understood these circumstances. I do not see how NMC will be able to submit these documents to their sponsors and get the finances to continue with this project.

5. Politicized: To a few people’s disappointment, we realized that the two top speakers were local politicians. One was coming up for re-election and used the conference to grand-stand in front of the press. The other was this politician’s opposition, injecting a further dose of political intrigue into the whole mix. We could not help but draw a link between funding for the Italian Government and the choice of speakers.

6. Disorganized details: A conference planned over two years should come off almost flawless. Well, at least that is what we expect in Canada. The first day, lunch took over 4 hours to get through (this, at least was fixed quickly), wasting many people’s time. The Internet had a limited connection of 250 people (while Bergamo, one of the main founders, was spouting a need for a social network…). People received their plane tickets only hours before their suggested departures. Only a handful of people were able to pre-register for workshops. There were no concrete instructions on how the event would proceed until we arrived. These were not explained in full, but only printed on paper and included in our kit. On the last day, we were asked by our facilitators to present our action plans to the NMC founding committee. Instead, NMC asked us (or at least this is what I understood) to comment on our experience thus far. When we did speak up (and I was not shy in offering criticism), we were berated and ignored.

7. The Organization’s Future: Just as NMC’s objective was limited, we still have no clear idea of what this organization will look like in the future. Will it be a series of conferences? An interactive website (they really need to fix the current website in this case)? Without having a clear idea of where this is going, it’s impossible to contribute. Moreover, I am surprised that donors agreed to funding such an expensive conference with a limited idea of what NMC would be after. A kick-off conference does not make an organization!

8. Lastly, I realize that my interest in the NMC concept was overblown. I wanted to assist with the webzine and the social network (I tweeted the conference quite vigorously, despite off and on internet connection, raising their profile considerably). However, when my suggestions to the conference founding committee were seen as an imposition, I had to re-evaluate my belief that these conferences are for youth, by youth.

To be fair, conferences are valuable. The network component in particular. However, $2,500,000 should deliver more than an informal network. If anything, they should have harnessed social media to formalize this “network” and began connecting us with each other’s ambitions and organizations through lists of participating members, biographies and so on. I would suggest the following measures:

1. Explaining how the action plans are being used to influence policy-making to all delegates who participated in workshops. Offer concrete examples or “proof.”

2. Should the action plans be insufficient to satisfy sponsors, honestly explain the situation to delegates so we understand where this component of our work went. This also shows that founding members understood the limitations of the workshop component.

3. Hire a team to develop, strategize and formalize this “network.” Through tools like Twitter, LinkedIn, and Facebook, out sourced from the main website, there is a chance to get a great conversation going.

4. Compile a list of all participants with detailed information on their fields of interest, experience and current work or study. Include email addresses and social networking contact information.

5. Send out an evaluation form to all delegates. Ensure that 60% answer. Compile and reflect on their advice publically on the website.

6. Give a detailed and transparent break-down of the conference budget.

7. Give a detailed plan on what the founding committee intends on doing within the next year.

{ 1 trackback }

Nicolò Wojewoda » Blog » Youth participation, according to NMC
January 28, 2026 at 5:13 pm

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Nicolò January 25, 2026 at 11:35 pm

@Aboyeji,
WYA is definitely an organization I’d be interested in learning more about. Another one you guys might want to check out is the Global Youth Action Network (http://www.youthlink.org/gyanv5/index.htm) who has developed a 5-step model to “facilitate youth participation and intergenerational partnerships in global decision-making”.

Reply

Siena Anstis January 27, 2026 at 8:11 am

Dear Nicolo,

Thank-you for your great comments. I agree on the “repetitive” bit - it was not my strongest argument, but I still think that these conferences, like you say, need to better network among each other to have a deeper impact (or an impact at all!).

As for the budget, $2.5 was the number floating around for base expenses (i.e. getting 500 delegates around). I imagine there was a lot more money in there for the event location, flying the speakers in, etc. I just could not believe that with that kind of sponsorship (the Italian government), they could not get their act together.

Lastly, it would be great to do a matching funds model - we could have chosen a workshop action plan to “win” and then be implemented (pending quality of course) by either the delegates or a youth organization who tenders for it.

Well, let us dream together and improve these models step by step! I contacted NMC with these suggestions, but, unfortunately, I do not think they are too willing to take outside advice.

As for One Young World (I recently joined their Facebook page, looks great!) and the Global Action Youth Network, as well as the World Youth Alliance, all interested initiatives. Will have to apply to participate in these programs at the next deadline.

Best,

Siena

Reply

Nicolò January 25, 2026 at 11:32 pm

Thank you for the insightful review, Siena. Let me add my two cents, as somebody who’s participating in another world youth meeting called One Young World (http://www.oneyoungworld.com/), and who has recently started blogging about global youth on my personal website (http://NicoloWojewoda.com).

Repetition: I don’t think multiple events are a repetition per se, since despite trying to attract people in the same target group, they end up having different participants. What’s fundamentally inefficient for me is the lack of coordination among them: ideas/resolutions are not communicated, spin-off projects are duplicated, there is fragmentation of funding and of human resources and the networks these events generate operate in isolation from each other.

For youth, by youth: some (very few) global youth meetings are entirely run by young people (here’s an example of a good one I went to a few years ago: http://isfit.org/). I don’t see any reason why events like the World Youth Meeting or One Young World shouldn’t be organized by youth, too. I hope to be making my case on this subject when I go to London in a couple of weeks, my suggestion for you and the other participants of the event in Bari would be to do the same in your follow up with the organizers.

Budgets: you say the World Youth Meeting costed $2.5mil? It’s actually a pretty decent number: that’s around $1600/person which, considering airfare and accommodation and food, doesn’t really leave much for other expenses. I’m still convinced that financial models for these events could be improved, though. For example, what about trying to squeeze the organizational expenses to $2mil and keeping $500k as matching funds for promising initiatives that are developed by participants?

Impact: I realize this comment is turning out to be pretty long, so I’ll just point you to my ongoing series of blog posts where I touch on this subject (and others) in relation to the effectiveness of youth involvement in global decision-making processes.

Looking forward to hear from you and others who join our discussion!

All the best,
Nicolò

Reply

mursya January 25, 2026 at 1:39 am

ready to sign under every single word

Reply

E Aboyeji January 23, 2026 at 8:33 pm

Not to self promote but I used to be a part of Youth Groups like these without clearly defined goals etc. I joined the World Youth Alliance and I think a lot of that has changed. They are a very focused group. There are fun activities but there is a draft declarations made months in advance which members just work to edit. Stuff like that. U shuld check it out. http://www.wya.net

Reply

Leave a Comment

Anti-Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Previous post:

Next post: